13th November
King’s India Institute
Bush House
King’s College London
“Please Remain Seated: The Cockroach, the Artist, and the Return of the Repressed”
1. The name that isn’t there
Before I start, I should tell you something I discovered while preparing this Nehru Memorial Lecture: In Delhi, there is no longer a Nehru Memorial.
The Nehru Memorial Museum and Library sits in Teen Murti Bhavan, the house where Nehru lived for sixteen years as Prime Minister. It holds the papers of the independence movement: the correspondence of a country inventing itself. In 2023, it was renamed. It is now the Prime Ministers’ Museum and Library. Nehru was removed.
Nothing was demolished. Nobody burned anything. The books are still on the shelves. A name was taken off a building.
I should say at the outset that I am not a historian or a political scientist. I am an artist. My professional expertise is in holes!
I have spent forty years taking material away from solid things, and here is what I have learnt. Removing something does not produce nothing. It produces a void. And a void is not just an absence — it is a presence you cannot fill. It is the loudest thing in the room, and nobody can quite say why.
I want to be precise about the words we usually reach for in relation to this. We say “censorship”. Censorship is when the state says so and so exists, but you may not mention it. Ugly, but at least it’s honest. It leaves the thing standing — you can point at it, defend it, smuggle it out, oppose it, scream about it, protest about it.
What is happening in India now is something else. It says: there was never anything there. Not a ban, but a deletion. And a deletion is much harder to fight, because you cannot defend a thing that officially never happened.
2. Please stand
Now a second scene.
Some years ago, the Supreme Court of India under fierce direction from government, ruled that the national anthem must be played in cinemas before the film, and that the audience must stand. The court later softened the order. But the habit did not soften. There are videos — easily found — of people in darkened cinemas being shouted at, dragged from their seats and beaten for not getting up fast enough. In many cases, people with disabilities.
The anthem reverses the whole point of a cinema. The dark makes you anonymous, and anonymity is what lets you feel things privately. Now the lights are down and everyone is watching everyone else. The screen is irrelevant. The performance is you. It is an extraordinarily efficient piece of theatre, and it costs the state nothing, because we do the surveillance ourselves, for free, out of embarrassment and enforced nationalism.
Now put those two scenes side by side. A name lifted off a building. A body pulled out of a seat.
There is your method, entirely. They take something away, and then they force you to stand up for what is left.
3. My title
Which brings me to the title of my talk, which is doing two jobs at once.
“Please remain seated” is the most banal sentence in the English language. You hear it on an aeroplane. It is an instruction to comply, issued in the politest possible voice.
But in India today, it is also a description of an act of courage. To remain seated is now, absurdly, one of the few gestures of refusal available to a person who has joined nothing and signed nothing. You simply do not get up.
The cockroach of my title, I will come to soon.
But the third part of my title is a phrase from Freud, which I will use once and then leave alone: the “return of the repressed”. You do not need any theory to follow it. What a society pushes out of sight does not stop existing. It goes somewhere. It comes back.
That is my argument: nothing they delete stays deleted. It always comes back. The only question is what shape it is in when it returns.
4. What is being deleted
So let me tell you what is being taken away in India today.
Start with the schoolbooks, because that is where a country tells itself who it is.
In the national curriculum, the chapters on the Mughals and the Delhi Sultanate have gone from the Class 7 history books. Not disputed, not annotated — removed. Six hundred years of Indian history, the period that produced the architecture the whole world flies to India to photograph, is no longer in the book a twelve-year-old opens. The passages explaining that Gandhi was murdered by a Hindu extremist (Godse), and that his killer’s organisation was banned afterwards, have been thinned to almost nothing. The chapter on the Gujarat killings of 2002, on Modi’s own watch as Chief Minister, is gone.
Understand what this is. It is not a lie. A lie can be corrected. It is a blank. In fifteen years, there will be an adult population who do not know that there is anything to argue about.
Then, I must mention the people: Academics, students, Dalit organisers, journalists, stand-up comedians — held for months and years, often without trial, under laws written for terrorism. Arundhati Roy is one of the most celebrated writers alive. In 2024, the authorities cleared the way to prosecute her under an anti-terror statute for a speech she gave in 2010. The United Nations human rights office asked India to drop it. It was not dropped. Bravo Arundhati!
Then the gundas, the RSS, the government’s gangsters. People abroad find it hard to believe they exist. Men who decide what may be eaten and by whom, and who may marry whom. And men who enforce it with their hands and their weapons, and make films posted online. Doesn’t it sound like the Nazi SS? I wrote about them in the Guardian eleven years ago and I was accused of exaggerating. I would love to have been exaggerating.
And then the deletion nobody counts as one, the economic deletion, which belongs to our list.
The richest one per cent of Indians now hold something like forty per cent of the country’s wealth. Economists who study this have found that inequality in India today is higher than it was under the British. Let me repeat that, because it is the most astonishing sentence: A country that fought a magnificent, world-changing struggle to be rid of colonial Empire is now more unequal than it was under the Empire. India has more billionaires than almost anywhere on earth — and, by the United Nations’ own count, some two hundred and thirty million of our people live in utter poverty, more than in any other country in the world. The average earning of a citizen of the USA (PHA) is $70,000 a year for an Indian it is $4000.
And in the same period the poor have been quietly edited out of India’s picture of itself — out of the advertising, out of the films, out of the self-image of a rising power — with the same thoroughness as the Mughals. They have not gone anywhere. They have simply been removed from the frame. Do we see the rich doing anything for our poverty stricken country men and women?
Which brings me to what gets built in the space where things have been deleted.
Five years ago, I wrote in the Guardian about the flattening of the Lutyens plan at the heart of New Delhi — in my view the greatest set of government buildings in the world, and great precisely because it is Mughal in its bones. A grand Islamic landscape, built by an Englishman, housing an Indian democracy. Three things at once. That is what India was.
What is going up instead is very large, ugly, and singular, built by Modi’s Albert Speer. There is also now a statue in Gujarat that is the tallest in the world, nearly twice the height of the Statue of Liberty.
I say this as a sculptor who has made some fairly large things in his time: but size is often what you have to reach for when you are not confident that the work or its unspoken language is any good!
That is the joke, but it is also the point. Monumentality is a symptom: you build something that enormous and asinine when you are frightened that the thing it represents is hollow.
Once again, I wrote eleven years ago that a spirit of fear was taking hold in India, and that we had never known this before. I was wrong about one thing: It was just the beginning. I will come to this further.
5. The haunting
But now here is the turn of the argument.
The Hindutva project is called purification: cleaning India of what is foreign to it. The trouble is arithmetical. Once you have deleted the Muslims, the Christians, the Marxists, the anti-caste tradition, the sceptics, the erotic, the doubters, the argumentative, the six hundred years of Islamic rule, the poor — what is left is not a purer India.
In fact, the deletion of India’s plurality is a deletion of India itself. There is nothing else there. That is what our country is.
And this is where the repressed comes back, in a form nobody enjoys.
Look at the language of the Indian government and its supporters over the last decade. What is striking is not the aggression. It is the terror. Love jihad — the belief that Muslim men are conducting a nationwide seduction campaign against Hindu women. Urban Naxals— the belief that the poet, the professor and the documentary maker are the operational wing of an armed insurgency. “Anti-nationals”. “The foreign hand”. When a youth movement went viral this year, officials briefed the press that half its followers were Pakistani. It was of course untrue.
This is not the language of a confident majority. Eighty per cent of the country is Hindu. It is the language of a haunted household.
A government that has deleted its own plurality then finds infiltrators in every room. It cannot sleep. The more pure the nation is declared, the more infested it feels.
And the tell — the thing that gives the whole game away — is in the vocabulary. “Parasites”. “Vermin”. “Infestation”. “Termites”.
You do not reach for the language of pest control when you have won. You reach for it when something has refused to go.
6. In the studio
I have been talking about our country, until now. So let me talk about the studio, because that is the thing I actually know about.
Repression at this scale does not mainly work through the courts. The courts are slow, expensive and embarrassing. What works is cheaper: it installs a censor in my studio, and the censor works for nothing and never takes a holiday.
You do not sit down and decide not to make a work. It is much quieter than that. An idea arrives, and you fail to pick it up. You find you are drawn to a different problem instead. That is the mechanism: no moment of cowardice you could point to and be ashamed of; nothing to confess; only a slight yet permanent narrowing of what occurs to you. You sensor yourself without realising it. You are your own Gunda because you know that should you dare you will be made by the government and its Gundas to suffer.
And here is the part I find genuinely frightening: that damage cannot be counted.
We know the wonderful artist Husain’s name, also because he was persecuted loudly enough to become news. Hundreds of court cases. Death threats. His work attacked in galleries.
He left India in 2006 and never went back. He died in London in 2011, at the age of ninety-five, and he is buried at Brookwood, less than an hour from where we are sitting. One of India’s greatest modern painters — a man who painted the Ramayana and the Mahabharata his whole life, who loved those stories — lies in English clay because his own country would not keep him safe, and why? Because he dared as a Muslim to paint Hindu Gods and Goddesses.
Nobody will ever count the paintings that were not made. There is no museum of unmade work. The most serious loss being inflicted on Indian culture is the one that will leave no trace.
Bhupen Khakhar was a dear friend and, I think, the finest Indian painter of my lifetime. He was also a gay man in a country where that was a criminal offence. For twenty years he painted the world sideways — barbers, watch-repairers, tea-shops, men standing about in the Indian street, tender and slightly absurd, all of it coded, all of it saying the thing without saying it.
And then in 1981, at the age of forty-seven, he painted You Can’t Please All: a naked man on a balcony, his own body, unmistakably, looking out over the town.
We rightly call that courage. But I want us to also ask what it cost us — all of us in this room, who will never see the paintings Buphen never dared paint, because they do not exist.
That is the psychic space that fear creates for an artist. Not martyrdom, but a narrowing. And a narrowing that is invisible, that is happening now, to people whose names none of us will ever learn and whose works of art we will never see.
7. The disobedient
So what is the artist supposed to do?
Let me first say what I do not think the answer is. I do not think the answer is political art. Political art is nearly always bad art — it knows what it thinks before it starts, and art that knows what it thinks before it starts is illustration. It also does not work. Nobody in the history of the world has changed their vote because of a mural!
The answer, I think, is something narrower and much more durable: disobedience in the material. Not making work about a subject. Refusing, inside the work itself, to do what you are being asked to do.
India has a long tradition of exactly this, and it is worth naming, because we are constantly told that dissent is a “foreign import”.
Rabindranath Tagore was the most honoured Indian alive in 1919. He was a knight of the Empire, a Nobel laureate, the man who wrote the words the cinema audiences are now beaten for not standing up to. And when the British massacred hundreds of unarmed people at Jallianwala Bag he wrote to the Viceroy and gave the knighthood back. He wished, he said, to stand beside his countrymen, stripped of all distinctions.
The present government reveres Tagore. It has also made his gesture — the public, ceremonial return of an honour by an artist in protest — the thing it punishes most furiously. When more than fifty Indian writers handed back their national literary awards in 2015, after a series of murders of writers and the lynching of a Muslim man over a rumour, ministers called it a planned conspiracy and an international plot. Among those writers was Nayantara Sahgal — Nehru’s niece, who grew up in the house that no longer carries his name. They were doing precisely what Tagore did, and they were called traitors for it by the people who put Tagore on the currency.
Amrita Sher-Gil is my third example. She trained in Paris, at the École des Beaux-Arts. She was excellent at it, but she walked away. She came back to India in 1934, and did not then do the other available thing, which was to paint sentimental nationalist pictures of a golden Hindu past. She refused in both directions at once. She painted Indian villagers with a modern European eye and without a shred of pity.
She died at twenty-eight, but she changed everything that came after her. Her disobedience is not in her subjects. It is in her refusal to accept anybody’s frame — not the coloniser’s, not the nationalist’s.
Khakhar disobeyed with his own body. Husain disobeyed simply by being a Muslim who loved Hindu stories — now the most provocative position available in India. And then there is Arundhati Roy who has been doing it in the open, under her own name, in her own country, for thirty years, at a cost the rest of us have not paid and do not understand.
None of these people made propaganda. Each of them disobeyed in paint, in prose, in form — in what they were prepared to look at and how they were prepared to look at it. That is the only disobedience art has ever had to offer. I call out to you colleagues, fellow artists – disagree, disobey, disavow – we have a duty to the poetic and as we know the rules of poetry do not exist, and if they did we must disobey them. Show your nudes, show your refusal – let them tear you down. We know that in the end poetry always wins.
And it has one great advantage over every other kind: It outlives the government that it annoyed. Nobody remembers who was Viceroy in 1919. But many know the letter Tagore wrotehim.
8. Cockroaches
Now I will keep my promise about the word.
In May of this year, the Chief Justice of India, sitting in open court, referred to unemployed young people and activists as cockroaches. Parasites of society. He said afterwards that he had meant only some of them. But that is not how it was heard.
Let me stop on that word for a moment, because it should not go past us lightly.
In Rwanda, in 1994, the Hutu Power radio stations called the Tutsi inyenzi — cockroaches. It was said for months, cheerfully, as a joke, and then eight hundred thousand people were killed with machetes by their neighbours. The vocabulary of vermin is not a rude word. It is the specific language by which human beings are prepared for elimination, and it has a body count. When a senior judge uses it about the young of his own country, that is not a gaffe. It is the deletion I have been describing, applied to living people.
What happened next is the reason I wanted to give this lecture.
Within days, as we know, young Indians took the word. Not rejected it — took it. A movement appeared calling itself the Cockroach Janta Party — a joke about the ruling party’s name, deliberately not a real party, contesting no elections. The hashtag [posted by Abhijeet Dipke] was Main Bhi Cockroach Whom —I too am a cockroach. They turned up at Jantar Mantar, the protest ground in Delhi, in cockroach costumes.
Within five days, the account had more followers than the ruling party. The government ordered it blocked on grounds of national security. It came back within hours under a new name: “Cockroach is Back.”
I want to name that operation, because it is the most interesting thing to have happened in Indian public life in a decade.
They took the word that was designed to reduce them to something you step on — and they wore it.
That is exactly what an artist does. It is what Khakhar did with the body he was told to be ashamed of. You take the discarded thing, the thing that was meant to end the conversation, and you make it a form.
And notice: this is the same return I described earlier, wearing its other face. The state met what it had buried and reached for the bulldozer. These young people met the very same thing and reached for a costume.
And the emblem is beautifully chosen. The cockroach is the creature that has survived every single thing ever thrown at it. It was here before us. It will almost certainly be here after us. It has outlasted every empire, every purge, every ideology ... and every very tall statue!
You cannot delete it. That is the entire point of a cockroach.
9. The void is not empty
I want to finish where I began: with holes, because it is the only expertise I actually have.
I have spent much of my working life making voids — apertures, cavities, dark places in solid material that people cannot quite look away from. And what I have learnt, over and over, is that people are wrong about absence. They think a hole is where something isn’t. It is not. A hole is a presence. It has an edge, it has a pull, it changes everything around it, and in any room containing one, it is the only thing anybody looks at.
This is why I am, in the end, not pessimistic — though I want to be careful how I say that, because there is nothing worse than an artist in London being optimistic about somebody else’s danger!
But look at the arithmetic of it. Take the name off Teen Murti Bhavan, and you have not removed Nehru. You have made an outline of him. Everyone who now walks past that building and knows what it used to be called sees the shape of what was taken away. Remove the Mughals from the textbook, and you have not removed the Taj Mahal, or the Red Fort, or the language that half the country speaks. You have simply produced a country full of children who will one day ask why the book stops.
The hole where a name was is louder than the name ever was.
There is a version of this in my own work that I did not choose. In 2015, I had a sculpture in the gardens at Versailles in Paris, and it was defaced with antisemitic graffiti.
My instinct was to leave it exactly as it was — not out of bravado, but because concealing it seemed to me to be the second crime. I was eventually compelled by a French court to remove the words, so I decided to cover them in gold leaf. I did not scrub them away. I made the wound visible and unreadable at once, and left it there, gleaming, for everyone to look at.
I offer that not as heroism — it was a compromise, and I lost the argument — but as a description of the position artists are actually in. You will often be made to obey. The question is what you do inside the obedience. There is nearly always a gesture available that complies and refuses at the same time. Khakhar found one for twenty years. The cockroaches found one in five days.
Nehru, in his book The Discovery of India, called the country an ancient palimpsest — layer written over layer, and no layer ever quite erasing the one beneath. He meant it as a description. I think it is also a prediction, and a rather comforting one. You can write over a palimpsest as hard as you like. The older writing comes through. It always comes through. That is the definition of the thing.
So: “please remain seated.”
In a country where standing up has been made compulsory, sitting still is what is left of freedom.
But I do not want to end by telling you what you should do, so let me end with something I am going to do instead.
I will go on saying this, in public, for as long as it is useful — and I will say it in India as well as in London.
I cannot make India safe for its artists. But I can refuse to be quiet in the one place where it costs me nothing to speak. Because the only thing that finally defeats a deletion is a thing that got made, said, or written anyway.
For as long as this lasts, I will keep a room for work by Indian artists who cannot show that work at home. I cannot make India safe for the artist. But I can make sure the work exists somewhere. Because, I say again, the only thing that finally defeats a deletion is a thing that got made anyway.
Anish Kapoor